Post GA: Anxiously awaiting the pronouncement
Written by Jon Spinnanger   
Friday, 06 August 2010 18:26
Now that the 219th GA has mercifully ended and the dust on all of the policy decisions is finally settling, what conclusions can be drawn?
 

            Permit me to offer the following analogy. In days gone by when an elderly relative died at home, those present at the time of passing anxiously awaited the arrival of the coroner, or doctor who would “pronounce” the departed legally dead.  To that point, however, the departed family member was, in fact dead, just not legally declared to be so.


            Is this where our beloved denomination is right now? We’re gathered around the bedside of the recently departed, saddened and shocked at what has happened (at the 219th GA), anxiously awaiting the dreaded “pronouncement” that our friend is in-fact legally dead. For the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), I believe, the “official” death will actually be declared when a majority of presbyteries vote to allow homosexual ordination – a very likely scenario given the support it received in Minneapolis last month. And that will be that. Moreover, unlike a departed family member, this death will bring about no wake, no funeral, no burial because — truthfully — this has already happened.
 

            To prove the foregoing, one needs look no further than what has already taken place in the Episcopal Church USA, (ECUSA) and most recently the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA). Both were once proud flagships in the American Armada of Protestantism. Both are now floundering in the surf, their “Great Commission Engines” having already failed, so if the rocks don’t get them first, then the beach certainly will. For these denominations the death certificate has already been issued. “Finis!” 
 

            Some of us in the PC(USA) are in local congregations that still adhere faithfully to the central tenet of our Reformed Faith: Sola Scriptura. To use another analogy, these churches are lifeboats secured to their davits on the flagship PC(USA).  As soon as the LGBT lifestyle is no longer a barrier to ordination, however, the question becomes: Will there be time for these already full lifeboats to get away from the ship before it sinks, or will all of us perish with the ship?


Jon Spinnanger

Williamsburg, Va.
Trackback(0)
Your Responses (4)Add Comment
Response from Tom Eggebeen, August 11, 2010
Los Angeles CA
The sky isn't falling, though things are changing, and seriously changing in our culture and all around the world. Yes, I agree, there will always be "denominational" structures of some sort or the other - human beings are social; we are joiners and we need fellowship. And there will be, for sure, Presbyterian type churches, both in style (open-minded and welcoming and committed to social justice) and in faith (serious about Scripture and tradition and worship centered in the sovereignty of God).

I think those who've made LGBT issues the Rubicon beyond which one cannot go have done themselves a great disservice. Luke 21 and our Lord's comments about the brevity of the Temple, already by then a thousand years of spiritual and cultural importance, remind us that what we build, and even what God builds (e.g. the Temple) changes in the tides of time. Jesus urges us to be calm and loving, and to put our heart into the heart of God, and not into the things we build, or even the things God has built. As Tom Wright has so powerfully developed in his works, capturing the power of Hebrews, Jesus is the Temple, and it's within his precincts that we are safe.

50 years from now, folks will wonder what this was all about, though, as with women and race, there will always be those who hanker for a time when their view of things prevailed.
Response from David Carothers, August 09, 2010
harrisonburg, VA
American Armada of Protestantism?? Who knew?
Response from Tim Leadingham, August 08, 2010
Post Falls, ID
The break-up of a denomination does not have to be a cause for weeping and gnashing of teeth. The Church of Rome fought sometimes violently against the Reformation from which the Presbyterians were formed. This is a chance for both liberal and conservative congregations to form new associations and relationships within the One Body of Christ, that are probably more effective in proclaiming the Gospel than PCUSA. Christ's Body is not breaking up, a human institution that no longer serves a purpose is. Christ's Body is diverse for a reason: to most effectively reach more people with the Good News!
Response from p.w. gregory, August 07, 2010
lambertville, nj
I always like to say it is a Constitution and Form of Govt., not a suicide pact. Each church and individual must process in their own minds and hearts the implications of any GA acts or change of polity. If the national church or denominational structure should vanish overnight would you cancel church or worship the following Sunday? Of course not, the Body of Christ goes on. Kids still will go to Sunday school and coffee will be served after church. Though many E.Ps and staffs will be looking for jobs, and I think that's the great anxiety in the church now.

As for the PCUSA, the national structure or some form of association will survive regardless of any matter with sex or politics of ordination. Post collapse of the national church, if there is one, the vast majority of denomination will movei into some form of organic union with the UCC, some churches will go Unitarian, given the syncratic nature of current theology, others will find other like minded folks to associate with, Quakers, New Age, what have you. And those what wish to ordain gays and alike will go on their way, others that do not, their way. The Presbyetrian church has experienced 14 major and minor schisms since 1823. Why is history any different?

Write a Response
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters

NOTE: Your response to an article will be reviewed by staff before it is made available to the public for reading. The delay may be a few minutes or it may be as long as 24 hours.

busy