Commission advises trial period for nongeographic presbyteries
Written by Leslie Scanlon, Outlook national reporter   
Tuesday, 14 February 2012 14:56

The Mid-Councils Commission advises that nongeographic presbyteries be given a trial run and that that synods be stripped of ecclesiastical authority.

The commission voted 17-1 to approve its final report to the 2012 General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.).

That report includes eight recommendations to the assembly, among them:

- Permit non-geographic, “provisional presbyteries” as part of a “designated season of reflective experimentation” in the PC(USA). The commission calls for the season of experimentation to expire in 2021, unless a General Assembly acts to change that.

- Recommend that synods would no longer exist in the PC(USA) as councils with ecclesiastical responsibility.

To take effect, both of those changes to the PC(USA)’s Book of Order would require approval from both the General Assembly and a majority of the denomination’s 173 presbyteries.

The commission approved all its key recommendations in votes during previous meetings, but delayed approval of its final report until a Feb. 13 conference call.

“It’s been an amazing experience,” said the commission’s moderator, Tod Bolsinger, in thanking the commission’s members for their work over the past 18 months. The 2010 General Assembly created the commission to examine the denomination’s middle governing body structure and to make recommendations for change.

The report states that at the heart of its proposals is an effort to flatten the denominational hierarchy and bureaucracy and set up regional administrative commissions. Those commissions are to serve multiple presbyteries through missional partnerships and by providing safe environments for collaboration and experimentation.

The commission also wants to reinvigorate presbyteries “as a locus of support for missional congregations by allowing more flexibility in the formation of connectional relationships,” the report states.

The report also offers lessons gleaned from voices from around the church, and from investigating creative approaches being used in the PC(USA) and other denominations.

“Christianity is like a river with many branches,” the report states. “Like others before it, the Presbyterian stream could run its course. It could disperse into nothing. Its water could run dry. But, it is just as likely that this stream will experience a resurgence of living water. For many, this is a time of hope and new life. It is a time of emergence and the birthing of new ways of being Christian – perhaps even new ways of being Presbyterian.”

 

Your Responses (1)add comment

James Cogswell said:

Black Mountain, NC
Editor, Presbyterian Outlook



I am sure that many Outlook readers have caught the irony of the two reports on the GA Mid-Councils Commission in the March 5 Outlook. The Commission recommends allowing non-geographic presbyteries, with the stipulation that a congregation could be dismissed to another presbytery within the synod. However, in another part of the commission’s report, it is recommended that synods be discontinued.



It is deeply troubling to think of further tinkering with the machinery of the church that would increase the number of presbyteries within the same region. Let me count the ways. (1) It would require that every congregation struggle with the question, to which presbytery shall we belong?, accentuating rifts within the congregation. (2) It would greatly increase the cost of middle judicatories (pardon the term), shifting resources from program to support of staff. (3) It would create havoc at the General Assembly level, as the two presbyteries within the same region vie to be heard and to affect GA policy. (4) Most serious of all, I believe, it would increase the introversion of the church, taking resources and support that otherwise could be used to advance the church’s mission both national and international.



To sum it up, I believe that such a plan would betray the genius of the Presbyterian form of government, which seeks to maintain the precious unity of the church while finding ways of being strengthened by its diversity.



James Cogswell, Black Mountain, NC
February 27, 2012

Write a Response
smaller | bigger

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy